We arrived with a party of 8 just before closing time and they were happy to stay open late to serve us!
Atmosphere was definitely as advertised, a shack. Seating and surrounding was bits and pieces of the what's left from stuff previously used and combined with holes in walls, disgusting floors, all the way down to the stained and dirty dishware they serve their food on. It's a nice and place to drink if your looking for the run down thing(mom and pop). Server was a very nice person. Just too run down for me.
Everyone was really nice. The food, ummmmm I don't even know where to begin. The bacon was just a big jumbled mess that tasted like rubber. The biscuits were like hockey pucs. The gravy, YUCK!. Paid 10.99 for the buffet. Didn't even come close to to finishing my first plate. Definitely did not go back for seconds.
Was very disappointed in their breakfast buffet. It was way too expensive for what you got. Potatoes were dark brown in color for sitting too long and no flavor. Fruit Cocktail? Coffee was not drinkable. It had been made and sitting for several hours. Syrup for pancakes was nasty...
We have been to the Shack several times and have never been disappointed. Great food and appetizers, with large portions. Owners and staff are always friendly and willing to engage in conversation if you want. Will definitely be back.
We joked all the way to NC about the Ye Olde Shack. But the biscuits and gravy was pretty good.
Ye Olde Shack is a US Restaurant based in Brookville, Indiana. Ye Olde Shack is located at 300 Main St, Brookville, IN 47012, USA.
Please contact with Ye Olde Shack using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Ye Olde Shack opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Restaurant in Brookville